Origins of Us Niche Skin Care and Hair Products
Human Evolution

Neanderthal

Origins of Us - Brains

With their tools, big brains and growing populations, successive waves of human species left Africa. First Homo erectus, the habd axe maker. A million years later, they were followed by another human species, Homo heidelbergensis. In Europe, they evolved into the Neanderthals. And in Africa, they became us, Homo sapiens, And it was from Africa that our species spread out to colonise the world.

 

With our large brains we flourished in new environments. But we weren't alone. We know from fossils and archaeology that our pioneering ancestor weren't heading into virgin territory. Around the world, there were uher species of humans already living there when we arrived.

In Europe, Homo sapiens were entering the territory of the Neanderthals.  Neanderthals aere a species of human very similar to us. They were a physically formidable competitor, heavily built, with short limbs adapted for the colder climate. They may have been strong, but they have developed a reputation for being dim-witted.

Within a few thousand years of Homo sapiens arriving in Europe, the Neanderthals, like every other hunab species before, went extinct. It's always been thought the reason for our survival was our superior intelligence.

Comparing a Neanderthal skull to one of Homo sapiens, Dr Roberts notes the differences. The Neanderthal has a massive brow ridge over the eyes, and a sloped-back, a swept-back forehead, whereas the modern human has a very slight browand then a very steep frontal bone, a steep forehead.

Neanderthal Skull
Neanderthal Skull

The faces are very different, but there's an overwhelming similarity here, and that is in the size of the brain cases. Neanderthals has about the same size brains as us. So if we're going on brain size alone, there's nothing to suggest that a modern human should be any cleverer than a Neanderthal.

So, if Neanderthals and Homo sapiens both had similarly large brains, why is it that today there's just us left?

At the Max Planck Institute in Leipzig, scientists are trying to understand the secret of our success at a genetic level. They have achieved what was once thought impossible, by searching for clues within Neanderthal DNA. It's incredible to think that it's possible to extract tiny fragments of DNA from the bones of somebody who lived tens of thousands of years ago, and then to piece together yhose fragments to get the genetic code of an extinct human. That genome holds clues to the workings of the Neanderthal body and brain.

Extracting DNA from ancient bones is a painstaking and complex process. Professor Svante Paabo is head of the team trying to compare our DNA with that of the Neanderthals.

Professor Svante Paabo
Prof. Paabo

What can Neanderthal DNA tell us about me? Prof. Paabo "First of all, what it confirms is that we are very close relatives to Neanderthals. We share a common origin, something like 2-300,000 years ago. Even since then, there have been interactions with Neanderthals, there has been interbreeding between Neanderthals and early modern ancestors. " Dr Roberts "So, in part, I'm a Neanderthal?" Prof Paabo Yes, The Neanderthals are not quite extinct, if you like, rhey live on in some of us a little bit today."

As well as showing a degree of interbreeding between us and our cousins, Neanderthal DNA has revealed clues about their brains. The team here has discovered that Neanderthals share with us the exact same form of a gene called FOXP2, which is connected with language. So it's possible they had similar abilities to speak.

The scientists are combing through the Neanderthal genome, the vast majority of which is the same as ours. But what's really remarkable, what they're really looking for are those differences, so we're learning more about Neanderthals and about what makes us truly unique.

While the geneticists continue their search for answers, if we want to understand why we're here, and the Neanderthals aren't, we need to go back to where they lived.

I've come to the British colonial outpost of Gibraltar. We know that about 10,000 years after modern humans arrived in Europe, the Neanderthals had disappeared. So was this down to us outsmarting them?

We know from the fossils that Neanderthals had brains as big as ours and the genetics is now starting to give us glimpses of what that brain might have functioned like, so we know we share a gene with the Neanderthals which is involved with speech. But the best chance we have of getting to know the Neanderthals and finding out just how similar or different they were to us, is by looking at the physical traces of their behaviour

Gorham's Cave
Gorham's Cave

Archaeologist Clive Finlayson has been studying the traces of our extinct cousins. Much of Clive's reseatch has been centred on a site called Gorham's Cave. Today, it's only accessible by sea. This cave has revealed much about the way Neanderthals lived and behaved, compared with the way modern humans were living at the same time.

It's amazing to stand here and imagine what it must have been like when the sea was so much furher out. Clive "There were times when the sea would've been much further away and all this would have been pine woods and wetlands, a little Eden for the Neanderthals."

It used to be thought that the Neanderthals had a very limited diet, mostly eating big game. But the cave has revealed some surprising finds. Clive "I can show you little bits of marine molluscs. The sea never came up here, so they would've been transported. And you can see the little flakes of flint, they were transported by people. It's clear evidence that Neanderthals were eating marine molluscs, one of these things which is meant to be a speciality of modern humans."

Beyond the food waste left behind, the tools they used tell us a lot about their intelligence. The evidence suggests they're just as intelligent as we were, but maybe did things a different way.

It's clearly far too simplistic to dismiss Neanderthals as being too stupid to survive. Further back in the cave, Clive has uncovered more evidence of ou extinct cousins. So, were Neanderthals living this deep in the cave? Clive "Absolutely. This was the big surprise. It's not a normal thing for Neanderthals to live at the back of caves." It's back here that Clive made his most important discovery. Clive "In there we excavated a half a camp fire made by Neanderthals and we got a radiocarbon date to around 28,000 years ago. And, to date, it's the last known site, the last place where the Neanderthals lived on the planet."

So, if they had brains as big as ours, and were just as clever as us, why did Neanderthals die out, while we went on to flourish? In the centuries before the Neanderthals' demise, there was dramatic climate change across Europe. The woodlands that Neanderthals were used to shrank giving way to open landscapes, where modern humans thrived. And, as the modern human population increased, the Neanderthal population declined.